Once More: It’s Always About Control

by Sam Carpenter

I wonder what he's thinking?

——————————–
(Here’s another self-anointed “best of” as I continue my mini-break from writing and as we prepare for the holidays with lots of  family, both in Seattle and Bend.  Thanks to all of you, and Linda and I wish you the best in this holiday season. -sc)
———————————

Its Always About Control
“…it is mandatory that we understand the machinery of our lives if we are to modify that machinery to produce the results we want.” -
From the book, Work the System: The Simple Mechanics of Making More and Working Less.

A couple of months ago I wrote a post about Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs. In the essay, I stated that each of us is driven by the innate desire for something more than what we already have. Here’s a further subtlety: For each of us, the “desire for something more” can be more precisely defined as the ”urge to acquire better control of our surroundings and of our lives.” (And I might as well add this: The more control a person exerts over his or her life, the happier that person will be.)

What we do in life is almost always about a search for additional personal control within a system. Consider the following random observations:

  • Via some protestant-ethic mental gyration, too many of us waste time refuting the simple fact that having plenty of money is a good thing.  It’s elementary: More money means better control over the mechanical aspects of life.  Find an ethical way to get more money and you will not only have more power over your time and surrounding environment, you’ll have enough left over to give some of it away to those who need help. It’s simple logic. Don’t confuse the issue.
  • I don’t blog to make a living so there is no need for me to run every word through some kind of a marketing-savvy/politically-correct content scrubber. This gives me stronger control over what I say. It’s liberating. If I were writing in order to sell you something, my thoughts would be more parsed.
  • In the West, the parent/child system of communication is often little more than a back-and-forth struggle for control. The ingratiated,  coddled child has been granted adult-like power so parent-to-child instructions are transformed into child-to-parent negotiations. Control has moved from the parent to the child. Sad for the parent and sad for the future adult.
  • Substance addiction is a black-hole system of destruction, and the ultimate example of loss of control. Not controlling an addiction ruins everything. (Interestingly, out-of-control addiction is the end result of misguided efforts to control a bad state of mind.)
  • Twitter. Really: How much real control does one get in making endless tweets? Face it. If you have 15,000 followers and you follow 15,000 others, there’s a whole lot of talking going on while no one is listening. Using precious time to spout off to people who don’t care is an act of delusional thinking and ultimately an act of non-control. (Do I  Twitter? Yes, reluctantly, but maybe not much longer. The same goes with Facebook.)
  • Nature: In unfettered-by-humans natural systems there are control-lessons everywhere. The cougar chases the deer. The deer’s act of control is evidenced in the furious sprint away from the cougar. The cougar seeks its own incremental dose of additional control by securing yet another full belly. The deer’s act of control is to escape. Forget anthropomorphizing theories. In unadulterated nature, it’s always about control.
  • Business and politics: No explanation necessary. Clearly these arenas are about control, and offering up examples would be condescending to you the reader.
  • War: Same as above but certainly the most gutteral illustration of the deep-seated urge for control. (I just finished the book War, by Sebastian Junger. It’s worth the read.)
  • Add your own examples. From the “control context” vantage point, just look around.

Most times, seeking more personal control is a good thing. Don’t hem and haw about it, or pretend the search for control is not a primary life-motivator. From Barack Obama’s agenda to Mother Theresa’s life work; from the act of buying a new TV to hailing a cab in the street, it’s about putting oneself out there in order to get a better grip on things. Once this inborn drive is understood from a non-judgmental point of view, getting a handle on the mechanics of life becomes simple and logical.

Here’s how I “work the system” in order to get better command of my environment and myself:  First, I decide exactly what goals I want to achieve. Second, I study and dissect the linear systems that I’ve aimed toward those goals. Third, since I can now precisely see how each individual system executes, I carefully manage the components of each of those systems in order to produce my desired goals. It’s a mechanical approach, and in this mechanical world the approach is profoundly effective.

This overt effort to engineer better control is called “management.”

Here’s the unavoidable qualifier. The title of this piece, It’s Always About Control, is flawed in an important respect:  Pure love doesn’t fit into this control-context. But that’s OK because once mechanical control of life is achieved there is plenty of time and energy left over for deciphering the mysterious.

If you liked this post, please pass it on. -sc
Photo by
H. Koop-Delaney, via flickr used under a creative commons license.

Posted on December 20, 2010

{ 7 comments… read them below or add one }

Julie Hood July 9, 2010 at 4:57 pm

Thanks for the great insights, Sam….. rather than giving up on Twitter, have you considered making it automatic (automatic posting when you have a new blog post, automatic posting across Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn with one post from Hootsuite, etc.) Just my 2 cents…. (and yes, I just followed you on Twitter!)

Pat Gilbert July 9, 2010 at 5:18 pm

You are thesis and I will be the antithesis, since I guess I might be stealing your thunder this will be the last time I comment on your blog, because I can’t agree with your thesis even though I do respect most of what you are espousing.

The psycho babble is just that and misses the mark and should not be alloyed with the concept of control as it makes a profound subject less workable if alloyed.

Another way to look at control is the ability to predict. If you can predict when a car is going to start, change, and stop you can control a car. To be able to control a business depends largely on the ability to predict. Predict how long something is going to take to do, predict how something is going to be done, predict how much you are going to be able to sell, etc. If you do arrive at the level of prediction you can create profit. It is sort of the make break point of a business or a life. You will find that a person has the most upset in life at the times that he lost control, drug addiction, divorce, an accident. On the upside he gains confidence and has the most pleasure when he gains control, winning a game, successful business, productive employees, successful marriage, successful children, etc. I could rattle on for pages on the subject of control.

Sam Carpenter July 9, 2010 at 8:59 pm

It seems to me a lot of the people who found me on Twitter came via an automated search program and so don’t even know what the Twitter account is all about. I wonder how many of the people who follow me see what I post. My guess is not many…If this is the case, I am not sure I want to contribute to the unheard chatter. The jury is still out. Tahnks Julie.

Sam Carpenter July 9, 2010 at 10:54 pm

It’s OK Pat! No thunder to steal. Thanks for taking the time to comment. -s

Darrin December 22, 2010 at 1:20 am

Great last sentence. That’s what IT is all about, right? Maximize control and effectiveness in order to have time to pursue the mysterious. Love it.

Tangent: in the email sent out on this, I couldn’t for the life of me find a link back to this post so that I could comment. Maybe there’s a way in your autoresponder/rss email to make the link more obvious?

Sam Carpenter December 24, 2010 at 6:52 am

Thanks Darren and sorry about the trouble. Sloppy on my part. I’ll review the link problem with my IT guy.

Eric G December 26, 2010 at 4:23 am

curious about your comment about parenting.. ‘in the west’. How is it in the East?

Leave a Comment

{ 2 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: